A Guide To Help You Choose The Best Pasta Maker | MakeBestPasta.com
Pasta making with eggs and flour

A Guide To Help You Choose The Best Pasta Maker

If your family loves pasta and Italian dishes, then you probably have boxes and boxes of dried pasta sitting in your cabinet. While these boxes of pasta are a great time saver, there’s something more satisfying when you make your pasta from scratch.

It shows your family your skills as a cook, but also that you care for them so much that you’re going to put in that extra effort to create a delicious meal. For families who expresses love through food, it would make absolute sense that you’d want the very best pasta maker that your money can buy.

What To Look For In A Pasta Maker

So you’ve decided that you want to try your hand at making your very own homemade pasta. Before you run out and purchase the latest product that claims to be the best rated pasta maker, you might want to consider these things first:

Cleaning

If you aren’t fond of cleaning and washing, you are going to want to find a machine that is going to be easy to clean.

Many motor pasta makers have easy-to clean pasta discs. You are also going to want to find a pasta maker that is easy to take apart and reassemble.

Homemade noodles, eggs and flour.

Adjustment Knob

You want to make sure that your pasta maker has a knob on it where you can change the thickness of the pasta.

Clamp

While most pasta makers do have a clamp that attaches the machine to the counter, this is something that you’ll want to double check for. The clamp is going to make it easy for you to make the pasta because the machine isn’t going to be moving around the table. Also, the machine should have rubber pads on the bottom to help keep the machine in place.

Manual Or Motorized

If you want an easy to use machine that will do much of the work for you, then you are probably going to want a motorized pasta maker. However, if you don’t mind working for your pasta, the manual option is going to be much more cost efficient and even easier to use.

If you do choose a manual pasta maker, make sure the handle is secure on the machine, as this is the part that is going to be doing most of the work.

Size

The size of the part where you feed the pasta in should be wide enough for larger sheets of dough. There are some machines that are 18 inches wide (or larger), but be aware that these models will be more expensive.

Attachments

Usually you can find pasta makers that come with various attachments like cutters, discs, and even pasta stuffers

These will allow you to make more than just flat noodles.

Marcato atlas 150 pasta maker attachments

Build Quality

You know the saying that you get what you pay for? Sometimes that isn’t always the case. You can find affordable pasta makers that are made exceptionally well, but they aren’t crazy expensive. You are going to want to look for a machine that is heavy, has a strong clamp, and uses sturdy materials.

The better the build quality, the longer the machine is going to last and the more use you can get out of it.

Now that you know what qualities makes for the best pasta maker, let’s take a look at some of the products that we feel will answer your question of what is the best pasta maker. We have chosen 2 products that are priced slightly above $50, 2 products that are priced under $50, and one electric pasta maker.

​*Notice: On mobile devices, scroll right to see entire table.

Best Pasta Maker Over $50

If you want to have the best pasta maker on the market and you don’t mind spending a bit of money, here are two great options worth considering.

Marcato Atlas Pasta Machine

The Marcato Atlas pasta maker is a manual machine that can make lasagna, fettuccine and tagliolini pasta. The machine will allow you to make a variety of flat pastas, but if you wanted to make other types of pasta, you can do that by purchasing a separate accessory for each pasta shape. The pasta maker features a bayonet fitting on the side opposing the hand crank.

You can attach a motor to the end if you need to make pasta quickly. This will allow you to choose which method you can use to guide the dough through the machine’s combing mechanism. The anodized aluminum material is going to prevent your dough from sticking, thus ensuring your pasta is not going to tear or break apart.

We like this pasta maker because it comes with a 10-year warranty, which only shows how much the company stands behind their product.

Features Of The Marcato Atlas Pasta Machine include:

  • Rolls and cuts pasta dough for making traditional lasagna, fettuccine, and tagliolini at home
  • Made in Italy from stainless steel
  • Includes Pasta Machine, pasta cutter, hand crank, clamp, complete instructions
  • Easily make 3 pasta shapes;
  • ​Easily attach a Pasta Drive motor or any of 12 pasta cutting accessories (sold separately)
  • Roll dough up to 150-millimeters wide with 10 thicknesses (0.6 to 4.8-millimeter)
  • ​Rolled dough ensures a more consistent texture, cook time and taste
  • ​Easy to use and wipe clean with a dry brush or cloth
  • 10-year manufacturer’s warranty
Marcato pasta maker with flour and egg.

Our Rating

When looking at the reviews for the Marcato Atlas Pasta Machine, most of the customers left 4 or 5-star reviews. Of these reviews, customers said that the machine was absolutely perfect for rolling out a flat sheet of pasta dough for raviolis. Customers like how quickly and easily the can make pasta with this machine.

They have said they can make enough fresh pasta to feel a family of twelve within a matter of minutes. Customers have said that the machine feels very sturdy when they are using it and they also liked the recipe for dough that came with this product.

The customers who left 3-star reviews or lower, the common complaint was that the knob that allows you to adjust the thickness of the pasta came off the machine only after two uses. Customers also pointed out that the socket for the handle of the machine broke shortly after they began using the unit.

A few people have said they received “knockoff” machines because the device didn’t have the “Marcato Atlas” embossed on the machine. One other person said their unit arrived damaged.


Imperia Pasta Maker Machine

With the Imperia Pasta Maker Machine, you’re getting an Italian made pasta machine that combines old-world traditional style pasta machines with innovative technology that makes this unit one of the best pasta maker machines available. The machine is made from heavy-duty chrome plated steel.

This material is excellent for the durability of the machine, but also makes it easy to clean and keep in good working order. You do have three color options; red, silver, and white. These color options are excellent for blending into any kitchen décor.

When you use the machine, you can use the two pasta rollers to create lasagna noodles, spaghetti, fettuccini, linguine, or even sheets of dough for raviolis. You can also purchase additional attachments to create a variety of noodle shapes or sizes.

Features of the Imperia Pasta Maker Machine include:

  • Exclusive, elegant and easy to use pasta machines
  • Prepares Lasagna sheets from manually prepared dough that can be then cut
  • ​Guaranteed to make fresh safe and clean pasta noodles
  • ​Do not wash - Never put in the dishwasher
  • Made in Italy
Imperia pasta maker machine review

Our Rating

When looking at the reviews for the Imperia Pasta Maker Machine, most of the customers left 4 or 5-star reviews. Of these reviews, customers said they love that they can take the pasta maker right out of the box and start using it. There is no assembly required and they like that it has a clamp that you can use to attach it securely to your workspace.

Customers are charmed by the old-world look of the machine, but they also like that the machine makes noodles of a variety of sizes. People who were unfamiliar with making homemade pasta certainly appreciated the recipe for dough that came with the machine.

When the machine is being used, they said that it works flawlessly, but they feel they have more control of the pasta making process when they use the slow setting. The customers who left 3-star reviews or lower, the common complaint was that the plastic that holds the spinner onto the machine isn’t durable at all.

One customer said the plastic piece broke within 5 months without regular use. Another customer said they were only able to use it 5 to 6 times before that piece broke. Some people felt that the clamp isn’t large enough to fit on thicker countertops like a butcher block table.

Some people have said that the handle doesn’t fit securely into the roller slot, causing it to fall out too easily.


Conclusion

Of these two options, we feel that the Marcato Atlas Pasta Machine is the best pasta maker. Although it is a little more expensive than the Imperia maker, the Marcato pasta maker has a higher approval rating among its customers, not to mention it has that fantastic 10 year product warranty!

Best Pasta Maker Under $50

The next two products are a couple of the more affordable pasta makers Amazon has to offer.

CucinaPro Pasta Maker Deluxe Set

The Pasta Maker Deluxe by Cucina Pro is a machine that you’re going to enjoy using. It is constructed out of steel that is coated in chrome to give your kitchen that sleek and sophisticated look. Not only does the coating look nice, but it is very durable and it will also be easy to clean.

You don’t have to worry about heavy duty cleaning because the machine doesn’t collect residue while you’re passing the pasta through it. There are seven settings that you can cycle through to get the pasta that your dish calls for, be it spaghetti, angel hair, lasagnette, fettuccini, or ravioli to name a few.

Features of the CucinaPro Pasta Maker Deluxe Set include:

  • Makes spaghetti, fettuccini, angel hair, ravioli and lasagnette
  • All attachments included
  • Made of chrome coated steel
Pasta maker deluxe set by Cucina Pro.

Our Rating

When looking at the reviews for the CucinaPro Pasta Maker, most of the customers left 4 or 5-star reviews. Of these reviews, customers said that they like how thin they can get their pasta with this machine, especially when using semolina flour which is often more difficult to work with.

People said that for the price of this machine, they were pleasantly surprised by how simple it is to use, and how many options they have for pasta. Customers have said that it’s a great little budget pasta maker and they don’t regret their purchase at all.

The customers who left 3-star reviews or lower, the common complaint was that the pads that are supposed to help keep the pasta maker in place while you use it is actually plastic which doesn’t give the machine much traction at all. People also mentioned that the since the handle is removable, it doesn’t lock into place.

This means they have experienced the handle coming off the machine while they are using it, which can be a nuisance.


HomeStart HST5018 Pasta Maker

There are some nights where you have your heart set on pasta. You start the sauce but when you realize you don’t have pasta on hand, you don’t have to run out to the store if you have a pasta maker! The name HomeStart tells us that delicious meals begin at home and you don’t have to spend a small fortune on appliances.

Case in point, this pasta maker is affordably priced (priced below $50) and it is incredibly simple to use. The machine features a clamp that will help you keep the machine in place while you are using it. This basic pasta maker proves that pasta making doesn’t have to be a big, complicated task.

With this machine, you can choose one of nine different thicknesses for your pasta. While you may not use all nine settings, it’s nice to have the option there.

Features of the HomeStart HST5018 Pasta Maker include:

  • Gears are case-hardened tempered steel.
  • Can free stand on the counter or use the included clamp for securing to a counter.int 2
  • ​Includes an easy to start Instruction booklet.
  • Easy Pull Handle regulates thickness of pasta dough ( 9 Different Positions).
  • ​Make Spaghetti / Fettuccine / Noodles and More
Making pasta with pasta maker

Our Rating

When looking at the reviews for the HomeStart Pasta Maker, the most of the customers left 4 or 5-star reviews. Of these reviews, customers said they liked how simple it was to use the machine, but also how easy it was to clean it after the pasta making was finished. Customers like that the pull handle works smoothly and it doesn’t require much effort for it to work well.

Customers like that the instruction booklet that comes with the machine is detailed and easy to follow. People who have never made pasta before especially appreciate the clear directions in the guide.

The customers who left 3-star reviews or lower, the common complaint was that since there is no motor on the unit, you have to manually feed the pasta dough through the maker. Depending on how skilled you are at doing this, you may find that you need help while using the machine.

Customers wish that the machine actually cut the pasta instead of perforating it and making you cut the pasta yourself. Some people have pointed out that the dough tends to get caught up on the underside of the cutting roller, which was time consuming to clean off.

Customers also wished that the cutting blades were sharper and the clamp was larger so that it could fit on their counter.


Conclusion

As far as pasta makers go, it’s understandable that you may not want to pay a whole lot of money but not sacrifice quality. We feel that the HomeStart HST5018 Pasta Maker is a great option.

Best Electric Pasta Maker

Sometimes we don’t always have the patience to hand crank the pasta maker. This pasta maker uses electricity so you can make a lot of pasta with little effort.

Atlas Electric Pasta Machine

Pasta is one of those food products that tastes totally different when it is made fresh from scratch. Some people find that making pasta at home is time consuming, especially when they are using an old manual pasta maker. Instead of using a manual pasta maker, why not give an electric pasta maker a shot.

The Atlas Electric Pasta maker is designed to last a life time, as it is made from chrome and nickel. You’ll find that the motor is removable, which makes the cleanup process so much easier. Also, since the pasta maker does us a motor, you can make a variety of pasta in a very short amount of time.

This pasta maker also features an additional attachment that you can use to create different types of pasta, thus satisfying your pasta needs.

Features of the Atlas Electric Pasta Machine include:

  • Make authentic pasta in your home with the Italian-made Atlas pasta machine
  • Body made of chrome plated steel; rollers and cutters made of anodized aluminum
  • ​Easily adjustable, 9-position dial regulates thickness of pasta dough
  • ​Recipes included in the instruction book
  • Includes attachments to make two kinds of pasta, motor has two speeds
Electric silver pasta maker

Our Rating

When looking at the reviews for the Atlas Electric Pasta Machine, most of the customers left 4 or 5-star reviews. Of these reviews, customers said that they were upgrading from a manual pasta maker to an electric unit and this was unit was the best electric pasta maker they’ve come across.

People appreciated that you can adjust the thickness of the pasta dough from 0 to 9, which allowed them to make delicate pastas if they wanted to. Several people have said that the machine is so easy to use, they allow their children to help them make fresh pasta and it’s a nice bonding experience.

Although several people have said it took a bit of patience to figure out how to work the machine, they said they were able to get a rhythm going and making pasta was much more fun.

Of the remaining 11% of customers who left 3-star reviews or lower, the common complaint was that the cord doesn’t stay attached to the machine, meaning the cord will fall out when you’re using it. This design flaw has caused several customers to return the unit and purchase another product.

Also, a few people said the motor on their machine stopped working shortly after they purchased the pasta maker. Other customers said that the roller works great but the actual cutting mechanisms do not work and it just have a deeply scored sheet of pasta that you then have to cut yourself.


Our Recommendation

All of these pasta makers have their merits. If you don’t want to manually push the dough through the pasta maker, you certainly will appreciate at the Atlas Electric Pasta Maker. It’s quick, easy, and efficient.

However, you are paying for the convenience, as it is priced under $175.

For those who want fresh pasta but don’t particularly want to spend an arm and a leg on an electric unit, we recommend the Marcato Atlas pasta maker or the cheaper HomeStart HST5018 Pasta Maker.

Basic pasta maker making the pasta

The Marcato device has a few extra features like make three different pasta shapes as well as a variety of flat noodles. The HomeStart is a perfect option if you aren’t looking for too many frills and just want a basic pasta maker.

Leave a Comment: